The trouble with diversity summary. Rhetorical Analysis of Walter Benn Michaels, Trouble with Essay 2019-01-08

The trouble with diversity summary Rating: 5,8/10 1787 reviews

Chapter 2

the trouble with diversity summary

Learning to adapt to new environments has become second nature to him. He convincingly argues that the emphasis on diversity in modern American life often obscures dangerous economic inequalities. Perhaps because women and minorities were more vulnerable in their status at the firm, they championed fewer people than white men did—they chose their battles, as one female evaluator put it. However, I can already see many pitfalls and how this book can be misunderstood in terms of there is no racism or gender inequality. Such a restriction today would seem as outrageous and unnatural as interracial—not to mention gay—marriage seemed or would have seemed then. Therefore, how can diversity advocates support their cause at the same time contending that we are all the same, genetically or otherwise? Metapsychology Online receives a commission from Amazon. To put the point more generally, books like The Great Gatsby and there have been a great many of them give us a vision of our society divided into races rather than into economic classes.

Next

Book Review: The Trouble With Diversity

the trouble with diversity summary

The considerable and sometimes obscure examples used to support the thesis are presented in a casual and scenic fashion where the direction is not always certain. Economic inequality in America is an enormity in both senses of the word. In other words, Benn Michaels unintentionally raises many questions which he then fails to answer, including the question of volition underlying the diversity craze, as well as how religious and economic ideology manifest in real life, and how they can exist side by side. The disappearance of jobs isn't. Scott Fitzgerald, Ernest Hemingway, and Phillip Roth. It encompasses all four resources of languages- argument, appeal, arrangement, and artistic devices. We look at our own lives the same way.

Next

The Trouble With Diversity By Walter Benn Michaels

the trouble with diversity summary

With more audacity, he questions whether all cultural traditions innately merit respect, such as ones romanticizing segregation in the South, or advocating genital mutilation, be they African tribes or the Jewish faith. If there's one thing Americans agree on, it's the value of diversity. In the early 1930s, Senator Huey Long of Louisiana proposed a law making it illegal for anyone to earn more than a million dollars a year and for anyone to inherit more than five million dollars. Usually my intellectual vanity prevents me from reading these bestselling political economy books where the college professor turned bestseller author mistakes readers for first year students and constantly and directly addresses the them with relatable examples. A world where some of us don't have enough money is a world where the differences between us present a problem: the need to get rid of inequality or to justify it.

Next

Metapsychology Online Reviews

the trouble with diversity summary

I don't have the book in front of me to get an exact quote, but to paraphrase, diversity just means we all have to change the way we act to other people, while true reform of the class system to bring about something closer to equity of opportunity would mean spending lots of money. I have three goals in writing this book. Hsu, a Taiwanese American author and editor, wrote this essay in order to express his views on the negative connotations that occur with some of the racially charged objects present in society. Since his goal is to get the practice of separating the races declared illegal, he immediately petitions for a hearing before the Louisiana Supreme Court, and then, after he loses there, he takes his case to the U. In Louisiana in 1896, he would have been called an octoroon--he had one black great-grandparent. In order to persuade his audience he connects with the emotions of the readers through the use of racial slurs that he has experienced personally. Michaels goes on from there to describe how we have come to warship diversity.

Next

Chapter 2

the trouble with diversity summary

Walter Benn Michaels is brilliant, and like many brilliant people, he's misunderstood by people whose ideologies conflict with his insights. According to Hemingway, in keeping with the protean tone and subject matter of his novels, rich people are nothing more than regular people with more money. The careful arrangement of these images indicates an obvious cause and effect strategy. The union workers who took a day off to protest President Grover Cleveland's deployment of twelve thousand troops to break the Pullman strike weren't campaigning to have their otherness respected. By having such an intense focus on diversity and inclusion we never really solve the real problem. Consequently, it is not brazenly declared that Blacks are athletically superior or that Whites are intellectually superior. Gilligan opened this award-winning show with Walter, underwear-clad, holding a pistol, next to a crashed R.

Next

Chapter 2

the trouble with diversity summary

Michaels takes no mercy on a the neo liberal project of moderatism, and in doing so reveals the very tragic ways in which we continue to accept diversity as a placeholder for material injustice and economic inequality. An argument that essentially treats opposing forces as evil is one that does not truly understand the motives of the acting party. Benn Michaels offers an initially interesting but finally very limited lens for understanding disparities in wealth and status in the United States. They actually stand a chance of improving decision making. Assimilation issues also apply to whether the United Nations should make attempts to preserve 'indigenous' cultures and languages. What determines whether languages are worth learning, for Michaels, is whether they are well suited to the job market. He even accuses the left wing party or liberals who have prided itself on working for social equality in diverting focus of economic inequality.


Next

On The Trouble with Diversity

the trouble with diversity summary

They listen to the same music, watch the same movies, and believe the same things about America — that it is wrong to be racist as an individual and to judge someone by the color of their skin nevermind the size of their checkbook! But nobody doubts that George Bush cares about Condoleezza Rice, who is very much a black person and who is fond of pointing out that she's been black since birth. If we managed to get rid of that legacy, we would also get rid of the disproportionality. Diversity has been a key tool in modern neo-liberal capitalism because as long as we all celebrate diversity in a non-threatening way everybody goes home happy and feels good about themselves at the end of the day and no one will complain about why all of the wealth has accumulated to the top 5% of the country. Indeed, as we have already seen, even when the difference between races isentirely articulated in terms of how you look--when the difference between the people in question is described as something absolutely visible, like the difference in color--looks can be deceiving. And suppressing minority cultures in order to lift individuals out of poverty was done at a large scale to the native people of North America and Australia in the early 20th century; it is now considered evil.

Next

Metapsychology Online Reviews

the trouble with diversity summary

Therefore, Michaels claims, cultures cannot be said to exist, either. But because neoliberalism has become the de facto arbiter of social justice, these same students see no reason why Harvard admissions shouldn't discriminate according to wealth. First because, for all I know, George Bush does care about poor people; at least he cares as much about poor people as anyone else does. No one is just female, or just black, or just Muslim. Bush probably likes some black people such as Condi Rice and Colin Powell. But Michaels maintains that this sort of inequality has less to do with race and more to do with class and the division of wealth in this country.

Next